Theodore Roosevelt in buckskin holding a rifle during his Dakota Territory years
|

The Marquis, the Murder Charge, and Theodore Roosevelt

Part Two of Three

On June 26, 1883, Sheriff G. W. Harmon traveled by train from Mandan toward the little settlement of Medora in Dakota Territory. He was coming because a quarrel between a French aristocrat and three local men had become serious enough to threaten bloodshed. By the time the sheriff reached the railroad station, that threat was no longer hypothetical. Gunfire broke out near the tracks, and when it stopped, Riley Luffsey was dead.

The Frenchman was Antoine de Vallombrosa, the Marquis de Morès, who had arrived in the Badlands less than three months earlier. He maintained that the men confronting him had fired first. One of the surviving men said the opposite: Morès and his companions had attacked without warning. The dispute would occupy the courts for more than two years, produce a remarkable amount of newspaper attention, and eventually draw another wealthy newcomer, Theodore Roosevelt, into the controversy.

Later accounts often turn the incident into a near-duel between Morès and Roosevelt. With a future president among the participants, that story has overshadowed Luffsey’s killing and the lengthy legal struggle that followed.

Land, Fences, and a Dangerous Quarrel

Morès had come west with a business plan. He intended to slaughter cattle near the northern ranges and ship refrigerated beef to markets in the east, avoiding some of the costs associated with sending live animals to Chicago. In the spring of 1883 he began establishing the town he named for his wife, Medora, on the Little Missouri River. As he acquired land for his operation, he fenced parts of it.

Ranchers moved cattle over open country in search of grass and water. Hunters followed established trails, some of which gave access to the river. As Morès fenced property for his operation, he collided with people who depended on those routes. The quarrel over access soon became a contest over who had authority in the valley.

Among those angered by the fencing was Frank O’Donald, a Texas hunter, along with Riley Luffsey and John Reuter, who went by the name Dutch Wannegan. The three were associated with objections to the new fences, and Morès’s associates reported hearing threats against him. According to the reconstruction in Sergio Luzzatto’s The First Fascist, Elbridge Paddock heard threats on June 21. Two days later Morès went to Mandan and asked Justice of the Peace Mark Bateman for assistance, including protection against bodily injury. He also called for the sheriff.

Contemporary newspapers sometimes portrayed Morès as a man bringing order to a rough district, with his opponents standing in the way of settlement. That framing minimized the objections to his fences and gave readers a ready explanation for the violence. The hunters had reasons to resent interference with familiar routes, and Morès had reason to take reported threats seriously. The central question remained who opened fire.

The Sheriff’s Arrival

On June 26, Morès was accompanied by men including Paddock, Frank Miller, and Dick Moore. Facing them were O’Donald, Luffsey, and Wannegan. The confrontation took place near the railway line as Sheriff Harmon and his party arrived from Mandan. The two sides exchanged gunfire, and Luffsey was killed.

In an account Morès gave to a newspaper correspondent shortly afterward, he said that O’Donald’s party approached with rifles and opened fire. He and his companions shot back. Morès described Luffsey continuing to fight after his horse had been shot beneath him, and said he did not know who fired the fatal bullet. O’Donald told a substantially different story: Morès’s men had fired first, attacking the hunters without warning. Both accounts were given by men with a strong interest in how the shooting would be understood.

Self-defense became central to the proceedings. Reports of earlier threats could explain why Morès anticipated violence, but witnesses still disputed who fired first. The presence of weapons on both sides did little to resolve that disagreement, and the surviving descriptions of the encounter remain contradictory.

Luffsey recedes from many of the later retellings. Most of what survives about him comes from the accounts of other men and the court reporting that followed his death. As Roosevelt’s role grew in the story, Luffsey increasingly became the background to a more famous quarrel, although his killing had brought the dispute into the courts in the first place.

The Courts and the Newspapers

The first legal proceedings moved quickly. Justice Bateman’s June hearing favored Morès and his companions, while O’Donald and Wannegan were treated as responsible for the violence. Another judge, Daniel Collins, reopened the matter in July, and further hearings followed. Modern summaries describe the charges against Morès as having been dismissed twice in 1883. A jury would hear the case two years later.

The competing accounts remained. Reports of threats against Morès strengthened his defense, but supporters of O’Donald and Wannegan continued to dispute the killing. The press frequently favored the wealthy newcomer, portraying him as a man attempting to bring employment and order to a region inhabited by troublesome hunters. French newspapers could be even more extravagant. Morès became a figure of frontier daring, his confrontation described as though it were an adventure suitable for an aristocratic hero.

The favorable coverage was useful to Morès as he built his packing plant and town. Reports describing him as a courageous peacemaker could cast his opponents as lawless and the killing as an unfortunate necessity. That version spread while the conflicting accounts of the shooting remained unresolved.

Morès could also afford a sustained legal defense. He had counsel, influential acquaintances, and the financial resources to contest the charges through multiple hearings.

A New Case, and a New Suspicion

While the Luffsey case worked its way through the courts, Morès continued establishing his cattle operation in a region where livestock theft was a persistent concern. Territorial law officers covered enormous distances, and ranchers frequently organized their own efforts to protect their herds. Morès favored aggressive action against suspected rustlers, and Luzzatto records that he employed a Pinkerton detective to investigate livestock theft. Theodore Roosevelt, who began ranching in the Badlands later in 1883, shared these concerns and joined other cattle owners in efforts to protect their property.

Roosevelt had arrived in the Badlands later in 1883, after Luffsey’s death. By 1885 he was operating ranches there, publishing about western life, and becoming acquainted with the people around Medora. He and Morès knew one another socially, visited each other’s homes, and shared interests in cattle, hunting, and life in the region.

They nevertheless had disagreements. In one cattle transaction, Morès attempted to reduce an agreed price from six cents per pound to five and a half cents after market conditions changed. Roosevelt refused the revised terms. The incident found its way into newspaper reports, some of which exaggerated the quarrel into a personal feud. The National Park Service describes their relationship more accurately as generally cordial, if occasionally strained.

In August 1885 the Luffsey case returned yet again, this time through a grand-jury indictment. Morès was taken into custody. He sought and obtained a change of venue from Mandan to Bismarck, arguing that local feeling would prevent a fair hearing. The renewed prosecution threatened much more than his public standing: a murder conviction could mean a long prison sentence, and his business ventures were already proving difficult to manage.

Morès believed that his enemies were helping to manufacture a case against him. One of the men who survived the shooting, Dutch Wannegan, had worked for Roosevelt’s ranching interests. Morès also suspected that Joe Ferris, a Roosevelt associate, was providing money or assistance to witnesses. Later accounts offer another explanation for the payments: they may have been withdrawals of funds held for ranch workers. Morès suspected Roosevelt’s involvement and wrote to him from jail.

The Letters from Bismarck

On September 3, 1885, Morès sent Roosevelt a letter accusing Ferris of working against him and asking whether Roosevelt was behind the effort. The Marquis reminded Roosevelt that he had thought them friends. He then added language about how gentlemen could settle such matters directly. It was suggestive without issuing a formal, explicit demand for a duel.

Roosevelt’s surviving draft reply denied hostility. He insisted that he was not Morès’s enemy, acknowledged the apparent threat, and made clear that he would answer for his own words and actions. The exchange concerned loyalty and personal honor in the shadow of a murder prosecution. It raised the possibility of a duel, although neither letter arranged one.

Later biographies added details about Roosevelt contemplating rifles at twelve paces and Bill Sewall offering to serve as his second. The National Park Service also recounts Sewall’s offer, while the specific weapons and distance come from later recollections. Hermann Hagedorn’s influential Roosevelt in the Bad Lands places the exchange after the trial, although Morès’s letter is dated September 3, before the verdict.

Luzzatto recounts a conciliatory turn in the exchange and a subsequent visit by Roosevelt to Morès in custody. The reported meeting suggests that the two men had begun to repair their quarrel.

The Bismarck Trial

The murder case proceeded in Bismarck during September 1885. Morès testified that the three hunters had initiated the shooting, and the defense emphasized threats that preceded it. Witnesses revisited events more than two years old, including where the men stood, what they carried, and the order in which shots were fired.

Hagedorn reports a disagreement in the testimony about the hunters’ weapons. According to his account, Morès said the men had emptied their revolvers before using rifles, whereas Sheriff Harmon said their firearms were loaded when surrendered to him.

The atmosphere in court was contentious. Prosecutor T. K. Long complained about the relationship between the judge, William F. Francis, and defense counsel, Frank Allen, who had previously worked for Francis. Francis held Long in contempt and imposed a $250 fine.

The jury returned its verdict on September 19, 1885, after approximately ten minutes of deliberation: not guilty. Competing accounts of the shooting survived the verdict, and the newspapers continued to revisit the case.

How the Legend Displaced the Case

Once Roosevelt became a national figure, it was natural for biographers to revisit his Badlands years. The exchange with Morès offered a ready-made scene: a future president refuses to be bullied by a French nobleman reputed to be a formidable shot. By retelling the incident as a duel narrowly averted, writers could illustrate Roosevelt’s courage without having to explore the harder and less conclusive history behind it.

That approach leaves out much of what made the encounter possible. Morès’s suspicions arose from a prosecution over a killing in 1883. His associates and opponents had been caught up in local conflicts about property, access, and personal threats. The court proceedings involved disputed testimony and strong passions. Roosevelt entered the case because Morès believed his connections were being used against him.

The evidence also complicates portrayals of Morès as an obvious murderer. Earlier threats had been reported, Luzzatto documents his appeal to legal authorities before the shooting, and a jury eventually acquitted him. The conflicting eyewitness accounts still leave uncertainty over how the violence began.

A dispute over land became personal and violent, leaving one man dead and others trying to explain who had fired first. The resulting prosecution lasted more than two years. Morès then came to suspect that another wealthy newcomer was secretly aiding his enemies, bringing Roosevelt into the quarrel. Their letters preserve the accusations, the hurt pride, and the effort to keep a feud from becoming another violent encounter.

By December 1886, the packing plant around which Medora had grown had closed, and Morès and his wife were leaving Dakota. The murder trial and the threatening exchange with Roosevelt were behind him. His later career would take him into French nationalist and antisemitic politics, far from the cattle business and the Badlands quarrels that had made him famous in America.

Next in the series: The Failed Cowboy Who Became a Precursor to Fascism.

Sources

Sergio Luzzatto, The First Fascist: The Sensational Life and Dark Legacy of the Marquis de Morès (Harvard University Press, 2026), chapters 4–5 and notes.

National Park Service, “Marquis de Morès”, Theodore Roosevelt National Park.

Marquis de Morès, “Letter from the Marquis de Morès to Theodore Roosevelt”, September 3, 1885, Harvard College Library, via Theodore Roosevelt Center.

Theodore Roosevelt, “Letter from Theodore Roosevelt to the Marquis de Morès”, September 1885, surviving draft, Harvard College Library, via Theodore Roosevelt Center.

Theodore Roosevelt Center, “The Marquis’ Case”, September 2, 1885.

Theodore Roosevelt Center, “The Marquis Testifies”, 1885.

Theodore Roosevelt Center, “The Marquis in Court”, September 19, 1885.

Theodore Roosevelt Center, “Trials (Murder)” subject index, including Bismarck Tribune reporting of the September 1885 verdict.

Prairie Public, “Third Trial for Marquis de Mores”, September 12, 2018.

Hermann Hagedorn, Roosevelt in the Bad Lands (1921), especially pp. 62–65 and 340–349.

North Dakota State Archives, Subject Guide to the Marquis de Morès, identifying the Marquis de Morès Papers, Collection 10036.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *