Main Street in Sturgis, South Dakota during Bike Week
|

Did Sturgis Get Its Money Back?

Ungoverned Money

At the end of 2023, the City of Sturgis reported $7,924,936 in long-term advances still owed to municipal funds by its tax increment financing (TIF) districts. Of that amount, $4,907,946 was owed to the Water Fund, with another $3,016,990 owed to the General Fund.

Sturgis had advanced the money to help finance development projects. The arrangements included interest and repayment schedules, some stretching decades into the future. The audits tell us how much remained outstanding at particular points in time, but they do not provide a consistent district-by-district record of the payments made along the way. So how much has actually come back, and have the districts been paying according to their agreements?

Different Districts, Different Repayment Terms

The city’s 2021 audit identified eight TIF districts with long-term advances from municipal funds. Scott Peterson Motors, TIF 11, carried 4 percent interest and was scheduled for repayment through 2033. Canyon View Estates, TIF 13, had a General Fund advance at 5 percent, scheduled through 2025. Woodland, TIF 15, had a Water Fund advance extending through 2035.

Trailhead and Smitty’s had schedules running through 2040, while Garden Grove and Hidden Estates extended through 2041. Dolan Creek was more complicated. According to the audit, repayment of its Water Fund advance depended on the city first satisfying a separate long-term obligation associated with the district.

A balance remaining in 2023 would not, by itself, mean a district with a 2041 repayment deadline had fallen behind.

The Growing Water Fund Balance

At the end of 2016, the Water Fund had $1,444,294 outstanding in long-term advances to other city funds. That balance reached $1,889,911 in 2020, $3,460,265 in 2021, $4,415,955 in 2022, and $4,907,946 in 2023. It more than tripled in seven years.

New advances and repayments both affect the year-end balance, so that increase cannot tell us how much was paid back in any particular year. By the end of 2023, however, nearly $5 million remained committed to long-term financing outside the Water Fund, which supports the city’s water utility.

Canyon View Estates and the 2025 Deadline

The 2021 audit listed repayment of Canyon View Estates’ General Fund advance through 2025. Yet the second-reading draft of the city’s 2026 budget still included $69,000 on a line labeled “Capital Appreciation – Int. Fund Repayment?” and another $6,000 for interest paid to the General Fund.

The same schedule had budgeted principal repayments in earlier years, but its columns for actual year-end 2023, actual year-end 2024, and year-to-date 2025 showed dashes on the principal-repayment line. Those entries cannot settle whether payments were recorded elsewhere or whether the agreement had been amended. They do leave a specific question: was Canyon View’s advance repaid by the end of 2025 under its original terms? If the schedule changed, where is the amended agreement?

Dolan Creek’s Separate Debts

Dolan Creek presents a different problem. The city’s financial statements describe the district’s long-term debt, a separate note receivable involving Dolan Creek LLC, and the Water Fund advance whose repayment was tied to the city’s satisfaction of another obligation.

The district’s long-term debt fell from approximately $1.69 million at the end of 2021 to approximately $1.12 million at the end of 2023. The separate developer note stood at $145,880 in 2023. Those figures track different obligations. Neither establishes how much of the Water Fund advance had been repaid.

Accounting Corrections in the 2023 Audit

The auditors also identified problems in how Sturgis recorded interfund and TIF transactions. The 2023 audit describes a misposting between long-term interfund advances and shorter-term amounts due between funds, an adjustment involving Dolan Creek debt, and corrections to TIF-related capital-asset entries. The city approved and recorded the auditors’ proposed adjustments, but the auditors found that the city’s existing controls had not identified the problems.

Another finding concerned five TIF districts: 16, 20, 22, 23, and 26. The city had not properly recorded certain TIF activity as capital assets, and the corrections significantly changed its general ledger and depreciation schedule. In its corrective-action plan, the city said it was seeking outside accounting assistance, with completion listed as ongoing.

What Sturgis Still Needs to Account For

At the end of 2023, Sturgis had nearly $8 million still on the books as advances to development districts. The audits leave unanswered how much principal each district paid, where the payments were recorded, and whether the city changed any repayment terms. Canyon View’s budget entries and Dolan Creek’s separate obligations are two places where the underlying agreements and ledgers could provide those answers.

The records examined here do not establish that a developer defaulted or that public money was lost. But with nearly $5 million owed back to the Water Fund alone, residents have good reason to ask how each balance was reached and when the city expects it to be repaid.

Sources and Reporting Note

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *